Skip to main content

System Dynamics in Financial Regulation

Another nail to the coffin

There is much hustle in Brussels as the EU market commissioner proposes steps to curb swap trading. The German chancellor presses for tighter EU regulations on hedge funds. In the UK, we are told, regulators seek tools to “burst dangerous asset bubbles before they are built”. Four banks, including JPMorgan Chase my employer, face trial over sale of derivative to Milan municipality, allegations that echo the role investment banks had in fueling Greek debt. It’s interesting that in the Greek and Italian stories the banks are cast as villains and public sector as a defenseless simpleton. But what is really amazing is that all these stories are reported in just one Financial Times edition. Things are moving at a dizzying pace. Financial policy is going through an overhaul.

Aiming at the wrong target

Meanwhile in the US, where the villains are the same but the simpletons are the homeowners, there is talk of a new regulatory body, the Consumer Financial Protection Agency. Though reckless mortgages are a real issue, it is not the most pressing one. Leverage and structured derivative products should be the main concern. While mortgages happened to be the raw material for structured products in the last crisis they may not be the building block of the next one. Creating a new agency is a more dazzling legislation than strengthening existing agencies (SEC, Federal Reserve) but is it a better policy?

Talking of new bureaus, Sloan professor Andrew Lo proposes to create a “financial industry crash safety board” that will investigate financial crises in the same manner as plane crashes. I am skeptic that will work or that it is necessary since there are numerous people probing into the last crisis anyway. But, I am proud to see that our professors publish such columns. Maybe that is why he is too busy to answer my email requesting to take part in his research group (-:

Sources

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/77069b0e-32bb-11df-a767-00144feabdc0.html

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704625004575090310653549910.html

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/011cbf2e-2599-11df-9bd3-00144feab49a.html?nclick_check=1

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Metallurgist mods made with Sloyd

Name: Stonebreaker Description: The Stonebreaker is a massive broadsword forged for the Onarks , its chipped blade a testament to countless battles, capable of smashing through stone and armor with raw, unrelenting power. Name: Bloodreap Description: The Bloodreap is a hauntingly curved scythe favored by the Saängwyr , its blade eternally stained with blood, perfect for swift, lethal strikes that drain both life and vitality from its foes. Name: Gilded Terra Description: Forged by the royal ironsmith from rare earth materials and gold, the Gilded Terra channels the elemental mastery of the Horas , resonating with the raw power of earth and fire in every strike. Name: Verdant Sovereign Description: A masterfully crafted spear with an emerald blade, the Verdant Sovereign channels the ancient Nature Magic of the Elari , striking with both regal precision and elemental fury. Name: Stellar Edge Description: Crafted using advanced alien technology by the Tingava , the Stellar Edge ...
Post a Comment
Read more

10 Recommended Readings on Business and Policy

Piles of business and policy books are published every year. While almost any book has something worthwhile in it, only a small fraction are good. And for every profound idea there is a load of simplifications, unbiased assertions, after the fact reasoning and hype. When considering what to read I know what to avoid. For starters, I’d avoid anything with a title similar to this blog title – anything with a number in it: “365 days of success”, “8 new roles of money” (from the Kiyosaki who brought us rich dad poor dad) or “101 ways to turn your business around”. I also avoid biographies and autobiographies. They tend to present a simplified view where the fortunes of companies and nations are over attributed to one person. This view is misleading and even dangerous when people start believing in saviors and messiahs . Autobiographies have all the flaws of biographies and they are also biased and are too often just pure narcissism. Finally, I won’t read a book about a company written f...
3 comments
Read more

Pitfalls in Performance Based Bonuses

Performance based bonuses (PBB) is an effective management tool but quite often it causes unintentional effects. PBB are supposed to improve productivity by compensating employees according to their contribution to productivity. However organizations are complex systems and it is impossible to measure an employee’s contribution accurately. Companies are forced to use performance models that are a simplification of reality. As a result, employees are focused on maximizing performance under the model which not completely aligned with the benefit of the company. In banking, for example, the bonus models underemphasized risk, causing a worldwide catastrophe. Leaving the financial crisis aside, there are other common pitfalls. It is simple to construct performance-based contribution for sales representatives. The more they sell the more they earn – simple. It is much harder to construct a model for back-end functions, say an IS developer. This is where it gets messy. Measurement by schedul...
3 comments
Read more